Court of Appeal
(Civil) (Amendment No. 4)
Rules 2014
Made 28th July 2014
Coming into force 1st
September 2014
THE COURT OF APPEAL, in pursuance of Article 19 of the Court of Appeal (Jersey) Law 1961[1], the Schedule to the Terrorist
Asset-Freezing (Jersey) Law 2011[2] and the Schedule to the Money
Laundering and Weapons Development (Directions) (Jersey) Law 2012[3], has made the following Rules –
1 Interpretation
In these Rules “principal Rules”
means the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 1964[4].
2 Rule
1 amended
In Rule 1(1) of the principal Rules –
(a) in
the definition of “respondent’s case” for the words
“Rule 8(3)” there shall be substituted the words “Rule 8(6)”;
(b) for
the full stop at the end of the definition of “respondent’s
notice” there shall be substituted a semi-colon;
(c) after
that definition there shall be inserted the following definitions –
“ ‘timings
letter’ means the letter referred to in paragraphs (1) and (2) of
Rule 8;
‘transcript’
means the transcript referred to in Rule 7(1).”.
3 Rule 3
amended
In Rule 3 of the principal Rules for the words “one
month” there shall be substituted the words “28 days”.
4 Rules 7
to 10 substituted
For Rules 7, 8, 9 and 10 of the principal Rules there shall be
substituted the following Rules –
(1) Subject to any direction of the Court or the
court below under Article 21(1) of the Law, after an appeal has been set
down, the Judicial Greffier shall, upon the request of either party to the
appeal, make a transcript of the official record of the proceedings at the
hearing.
(2) The transcript shall be furnished to the
appellant and to every other party to the appeal upon payment of such charges
as are fixed for the time being by rules of court pursuant to Article 21(4)
of the Law.
8 Timetable,
directions etc. for the appeal
(1) Within 7 days of receiving the notice
of appeal in accordance with Rule 4(2), the Judicial Greffier shall
prepare and circulate to each of the parties to the appeal a timings letter.
(2) The timings letter will –
(a) contain a timetable of the dates by which
submissions and other documents referred to in this Rule are to be lodged with
the Judicial Greffier;
(b) specify the manner, including the number of
copies of documents to be lodged, in which the other matters referred to in
this Rule are to be completed; and
(c) specify the sitting of the Court at which
the appeal is scheduled to be heard,
and may deal with any
ancillary timetabling or related matter if expedient to do so.
(3) The Judicial Greffier may at any stage of
the appeal issue to the parties a supplementary or revised timings letter if
the Judicial Greffier, on application by any party to the appeal, or otherwise,
thinks it expedient to do so; and, if a supplementary or revised timings letter
is issued, references in these Rules to the timings letter shall be construed
as references to the timings letter as so supplemented or revised.
(4) The appellant shall, in accordance with the
timetable and in the manner specified in the timings letter, lodge with the
Judicial Greffier –
(a) the acts or other documents containing the
pleadings and proceedings in the court below, including –
(i) the
order, judgment, decree or award under appeal,
(ii) so
much of the legislation referred to, and of all documentary or other material
produced, in the court below as is considered germane to the appeal;
(b) the notice of appeal;
(c) such parts of the transcript as are
considered germane to the appeal;
(d) where evidence was taken on affidavit, on
commission or before the Viscount, such affidavit or the official record of
such evidence given on commission or before the Viscount as is considered
germane to the appeal;
(e) the contentions to be urged and the
authorities to be cited by the appellant in support of the appellant’s
appeal (hereinafter referred to as the ‘appellant’s case’).
(5) When the appellant has complied with paragraph (4)
he or she shall, within 2 days, deliver to all parties on whom the notice
of appeal was served a copy of the appellant’s case.
(6) A respondent shall, in accordance with the
timetable and in the manner specified in the timings letter, lodge with the
Judicial Greffier the contentions to be urged and the authorities (to the
extent that they are additional to those contained in the appellant’s
case) to be cited by the respondent at the hearing of the appeal (hereinafter
referred to as a ‘respondent’s case’).
(7) When a respondent has complied with paragraph (5)
he or she shall, within 2 days, deliver to the appellant a copy of the
respondent’s case.
9 Notification
of hearing of appeal
No later than 7 days
before the first day of the sitting of the Court at which the appeal is
scheduled to be heard, the Judicial Greffier shall circulate to each of the
parties, or to his or her advocate or solicitor, a copy of the Court’s
agenda for the relevant sitting.
10 Abandonment
of appeal by non-prosecution
Subject to Rule 16, if
the appellant has not complied with Rule 8(4), the appellant’s
appeal shall be deemed to have been abandoned.”.
5 Rule 14
amended
In Rule 14(b) of the principal Rules, the words “of the
official shorthand note” shall be deleted.
6 Rule 18A
inserted
After Rule 18 of the principal Rules there shall be inserted
the following Rule –
“18A Appeals from proceedings under the
Terrorist Asset-Freezing and Money Laundering and Weapons Development Laws
‘2011 Law’ means
the Terrorist Asset-Freezing (Jersey) Law 2011[5];
‘2012 Law’ means
the Money Laundering and Weapons Development (Directions) (Jersey) Law 2012[6];
‘appeal’ means an
appeal against a decision of the Royal Court in proceedings under Article 28
or Article 29 of the 2011 Law or under Article 10 of the 2012
Law.
(2) These Rules apply to an appeal subject to paragraphs (3)
and (4).
(3) Any special counsel appointed in the
proceedings shall be taken to be a party directly affected by the appeal for
the purposes of Rule 2(4) and by the contentions of the respondent for the
purposes of Rule 5(4).
(4) Rules 16A/7 to 16A/17 of the Royal
Court Rules 2004 shall apply in relation to the appeal proceedings as they
did in relation to the proceedings in the court below with the following
modifications –
(a) references to the appellant or applicant in
the proceedings in the court below shall be taken to refer to the appellant in
the appeal;
(b) references to the Court shall be taken to
refer to the Court of Appeal, or a judge thereof; and
(c) the reference in Rule 16A/7(1)(b) to
the Chief Minister shall be construed as a reference to the respondent in the
appeal.”.
7 Citation
and commencement
These Rules may be cited as the Court of Appeal (Civil) (Amendment
No. 4) Rules 2014 and shall come into force on 1st September 2014.
C.J. COLEMAN
Assistant Judicial Greffier